The clean staples guide · US products

Grass-fed & organic butter, compared.

Compare grass-fed and organic claims without treating them as the same thing. Check the ingredients and find where to buy the exact butter you want.

What “clean” means here

Ingredients checked against your selected additives, with producer claims shown separately. This is not a nutrition or safety rating.

3 of 3 products · Click a brand for label notes

Edit my avoid list →

Sort by

Butter: sourced claims, selected additives, observed price per ounce, and buying options
				Where to buy
	Made with milk from grass-fed cows	Selected additives not found	Check seller price	Find a store
The saved ingredient label Pasteurized cream, salt Label checked 2026-10-04 · US Open full ingredient check → What the producer says The product page makes a grass-fed milk claim. It does not identify this butter as certified organic. Compare the block with sticks and blended spreads carefully. Producer claim source ↗ Claims reviewed 2026-10-05 Ingredient evidence source ↗
	Grass-fed claim not reviewed	Selected additives not found	Check seller price	Where to buy
The saved ingredient label Sweet Cream, Salt. Label checked 2026-10-04 · US Open full ingredient check → What the producer says Included as a conventional butter comparison. No grass-fed or organic claim has been verified for this record. Open the ingredient check to compare its saved label. Producer claim source ↗ Claims reviewed 2026-10-05 Ingredient evidence source ↗
	Organic · pasture-raised milk	Selected additives not found	Check seller price	Find where to buy
The saved ingredient label Organic sweet cream, salt Label checked 2026-10-04 · US Open full ingredient check → What the producer says This specific butter is described as organic and made with pasture-raised milk. The product page does not establish a 100% grass-fed claim for this variant; a site-wide logo is not product evidence. Producer claim source ↗ Claims reviewed 2026-10-05 Ingredient evidence source ↗

Buying links currently have no affiliate tracking. Buying links do not influence ingredient results. Amazon links open the producer’s store; confirm the exact product and stock there. Price observations expire after 30 days.

Before you buy

What to verify on the label.

Organic and grass-fed are separate claims. Check for both on the exact package if both matter to you.
Choose the exact variant: salted, unsalted, sticks, or a spread with added oils.
Local prices vary. Use the brand’s buying options and compare the same net weight.

A few useful answers

Is organic butter always grass-fed?

These are separate claims. Our Organic Valley record supports organic and pasture-raised milk claims; we have not verified a 100% grass-fed claim for that specific butter.

Do you have a verified organic and grass-fed butter?

None of the butter records currently in this guide has both claims verified. Selecting both filters will show that gap rather than suggest an unsupported match.

Why is there no butter price per ounce?

We have not verified a current retailer price for these exact packages. Find a store and compare its price against the package weight.