# Butter: compare ingredients

Source: https://cleanfoodscore.com/guides/compare-butter · Labels checked through 2026-11-21 · 69 of 91 products have a current, complete label

## Short answer

Of the 69 butter we can score by label, 60 list none of the nine additive groups we check. The top label is Organic Valley Organic Salted Butter (100/100): 2 ingredients, no added oil, no sweetener listed, none of the 9 additive groups we check. The group listed most often on this shelf is seed oils (9 labels).

## Ranked: 69 labels

| Rank | Product | Score | Added sugar / serving | Sodium / serving | Ingredients | Why | Label |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 1 | Organic Valley Organic Salted Butter | 100 | not recorded | not recorded | 2 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener; organic claim +25; grass-fed/pasture claim +15 | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/organic-valley-salted-butter |
| 2 | Clover Sonoma Organic Salted Butter | 85 | not recorded | not recorded | 2 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener; organic claim +25 | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/catalog-clover-organic-sweet-cream-salted-butter |
| 3 | Nancy's Organic Unsalted Butter | 85 | not recorded | not recorded | 2 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener; organic claim +25 | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/catalog-nancys-unsalted-butter |
| 4 | Organic Valley Organic Unsalted Butter | 85 | not recorded | not recorded | 2 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener; organic claim +25 | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/catalog-organicvalley-unsalted-butter |
| 5 | Clover Sonoma Organic Unsalted Butter | 85 | not recorded | not recorded | 3 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener; organic claim +25 | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/catalog-clover-organic-sweet-cream-unsalted-butter |
| 6 | Nancy's Organic Sea Salted Butter | 85 | not recorded | not recorded | 3 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener; organic claim +25 | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/catalog-nancys-sea-salted-butter |
| 7 | Organic Valley Organic Butter with Olive Oil | 85 | not recorded | not recorded | 4 | No flagged additive; olive oil; no sweetener; organic claim +25 | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/catalog-organicvalley-butter-with-olive-oil |
| 8 | Kerrygold Pure Irish Butter, Salted | 75 | not recorded | not recorded | 2 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener; grass-fed/pasture claim +15 | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/kerrygold-salted-butter |
| 9 | Maple Hill Salted Butter | 75 | not recorded | not recorded | 2 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener; grass-fed/pasture claim +15 | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/catalog-maplehill-salted-butter |
| 10 | Maple Hill Unsalted Butter | 75 | not recorded | not recorded | 2 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener; grass-fed/pasture claim +15 | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/catalog-maplehill-unsalted-butter |
| 11 | Good & Gather Salted Butter | 60 | 0 g | 90 mg | 2 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/usda-2605227 |
| 12 | Kirkland Signature Salted Sweet Cream Butter | 60 | 0 g | 90 mg | 2 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/usda-2329482 |
| 13 | Land O Lakes Salted Butter Balls | 60 | not recorded | 90 mg | 1 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/usda-2615136 |
| 14 | 365 by Whole Foods Market Salted Butter | 60 | not recorded | 90 mg | 2 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/usda-2424977 |
| 15 | 4th & Heart Garlic Ghee | 60 | not recorded | not recorded | 2 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/catalog-fourthheart-garlic-ghee |
| 16 | 4th & Heart Himalayan Pink Salt Ghee | 60 | not recorded | not recorded | 2 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/catalog-fourthheart-himalayan-pink-salt-ghee |
| 17 | Breakstone's All Natural Salted Butter | 60 | not recorded | 90 mg | 2 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/usda-2614608 |
| 18 | Challenge Butter | 60 | not recorded | not recorded | 2 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/catalog-challenge-butter |
| 19 | Challenge Butter European Style Butter | 60 | not recorded | not recorded | 2 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/catalog-challenge-european-style-butter |
| 20 | Challenge Butter Salted Butter | 60 | not recorded | 90 mg | 2 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/usda-2018099 |
| 21 | Challenge Butter Unsalted Butter | 60 | not recorded | 0 mg | 2 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/usda-2282791 |
| 22 | Challenge Butter Whipped Butter | 60 | not recorded | not recorded | 2 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/catalog-challenge-whipped-butter |
| 23 | Clover Sonoma European Salted Butter | 60 | not recorded | not recorded | 2 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/catalog-clover-european-style-salted-butter |
| 24 | Clover Sonoma Sweet Cream Salted Butter | 60 | not recorded | not recorded | 2 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/catalog-clover-sweet-cream-salted-butter |
| 25 | Great Value Butter Salted Sticks | 60 | not recorded | 90 mg | 2 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/usda-2375065 |
| 26 | GreenWise Unsalted Butter | 60 | not recorded | 0 mg | 2 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/usda-2423531 |
| 27 | Kate's Sea Salted Butter | 60 | not recorded | not recorded | 2 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/catalog-kates-sea-salted-butter |
| 28 | Kate's Sea Salted ButterCup | 60 | not recorded | not recorded | 2 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/catalog-kates-salted-buttercup |
| 29 | Kerrygold High Heat Cooking Butter | 60 | not recorded | not recorded | 2 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/catalog-kerrygold-high-heat-cooking-butter |
| 30 | Kerrygold Naturally Softer Irish Butter | 60 | not recorded | not recorded | 2 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/catalog-kerrygold-naturally-softer-irish-butter |
| 31 | Kerrygold Pure Irish Butter Sticks | 60 | not recorded | 100 mg | 2 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/usda-2642910 |
| 32 | Kroger Salted Butter | 60 | not recorded | 90 mg | 2 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/usda-2410942 |
| 33 | Land O Lakes Salted Butter | 60 | not recorded | 90 mg | 2 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/usda-2615133 |
| 34 | Land O Lakes Unsalted Butter | 60 | not recorded | 0 mg | 2 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/usda-2658385 |
| 35 | Land O Lakes Whipped Unsalted Butter | 60 | not recorded | 0 mg | 2 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/usda-2615137 |
| 36 | Land O'Lakes Extra Creamy Salted Butter | 60 | not recorded | not recorded | 2 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/catalog-landolakes-extra-creamy-salted-butter |
| 37 | Land O'Lakes Salted Butter | 60 | not recorded | not recorded | 2 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/land-o-lakes-salted-butter |
| 38 | Land O'Lakes Salted Whipped Butter | 60 | not recorded | not recorded | 2 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/catalog-landolakes-salted-whipped-butter |
| 39 | Land O'Lakes Unsalted Butter | 60 | not recorded | not recorded | 2 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/catalog-landolakes-unsalted-butter |
| 40 | Minerva Dairy Sea Salt Butter | 60 | not recorded | not recorded | 2 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/catalog-minerva-8oz-sea-salt-butter |
| 41 | Minerva Dairy Unsalted Butter | 60 | not recorded | not recorded | 2 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/catalog-minerva-8oz-unsalted-butter |
| 42 | O Organics Salted Sweet Cream Butter | 60 | not recorded | 90 mg | 2 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/usda-2505627 |
| 43 | Publix Unsalted Sweet Cream Butter | 60 | not recorded | 0 mg | 2 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/usda-2313783 |
| 44 | Sierra Nevada Cheese Co. Bella Capra Goat Butter | 60 | not recorded | not recorded | 2 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/catalog-sierranevada-bella-capra-goat-butter |
| 45 | Sierra Nevada Cheese Co. Graziers Butter Unsalted | 60 | not recorded | not recorded | 2 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/catalog-sierranevada-graziers-butter-unsalted |
| 46 | Sierra Nevada Cheese Co. Natural Unsalted Butter | 60 | not recorded | not recorded | 2 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/catalog-sierranevada-1lb-natural-unsalted-butter-log |
| 47 | Tillamook Salted Sweet Cream Butter | 60 | not recorded | 90 mg | 2 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/usda-2657436 |
| 48 | Tillamook Sweet Cream Butter | 60 | not recorded | 0 mg | 2 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/usda-2023953 |
| 49 | Vermont Creamery Unsalted Cultured Butter | 60 | not recorded | not recorded | 2 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/catalog-vermont-unsalted-cultured-butter |
| 50 | Clover Sonoma European Unsalted Butter | 60 | not recorded | not recorded | 3 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/catalog-clover-european-style-unsalted-butter |
| 51 | Clover Sonoma Sweet Cream Unsalted Butter | 60 | not recorded | not recorded | 3 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/catalog-clover-sweet-cream-unsalted-butter |
| 52 | Kerrygold Unsalted Butter | 60 | not recorded | not recorded | 3 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/catalog-kerrygold-unsalted-butter |
| 53 | Plugra Salted Butter | 60 | not recorded | 90 mg | 3 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/usda-2284798 |
| 54 | Sierra Nevada Cheese Co. Graziers Butter Salted | 60 | not recorded | not recorded | 3 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/catalog-sierranevada-graziers-butter-salted-8oz |
| 55 | Sierra Nevada Cheese Co. Natural Salted Butter | 60 | not recorded | not recorded | 3 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/catalog-sierranevada-1lb-natural-salted-butter-log |
| 56 | Kerrygold Irish Butter with Avocado Oil | 60 | not recorded | not recorded | 4 | No flagged additive; avocado oil; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/catalog-kerrygold-irish-butter-with-avocado-oil |
| 57 | Land O'Lakes Butter with Olive Oil & Sea Salt | 60 | not recorded | not recorded | 4 | No flagged additive; olive oil; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/catalog-landolakes-butter-with-olive-oil-sea-salt |
| 58 | Minerva Dairy Garlic Herb Butter | 60 | not recorded | not recorded | 5 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/catalog-minerva-8-oz-garlic-herb-butter |
| 59 | Plugrá Extra Creamy Butter with Olive Oil and Sea Salt | 60 | not recorded | not recorded | 5 | No flagged additive; olive oil; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/catalog-plugra-butter-with-olive-oil-and-sea-salt |
| 60 | Kerrygold Garlic & Herb Butter | 60 | not recorded | not recorded | 8 | No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/catalog-kerrygold-garlic-herb-butter |
| 61 | 4th & Heart Ghee Spray | 53 | not recorded | not recorded | 3 | Lists seed oils; avocado, grapeseed oil; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/catalog-fourthheart-ghee-oil-spray |
| 62 | Challenge Butter Spreadable Butter | 53 | not recorded | not recorded | 3 | Lists seed oils; canola oil; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/catalog-challenge-spreadable-butter |
| 63 | Land O'Lakes Butter with Canola Oil | 53 | not recorded | not recorded | 3 | Lists seed oils; canola oil; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/catalog-landolakes-butter-with-canola-oil |
| 64 | Challenge Butter Lactose Free Spreadable Butter | 53 | not recorded | not recorded | 4 | Lists seed oils; canola oil; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/catalog-challenge-lactose-free-spreadable-butter |
| 65 | I Can't Believe It's Not Butter! 28% Vegetable Oil Spread, Light | 53 | not recorded | 85 mg | 10 | Lists seed oils; soybean, palm oil; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/usda-2619215 |
| 66 | I Can't Believe It's Not Butter! 79% Vegetable Oil Spread Butter | 53 | not recorded | 100 mg | 10 | Lists seed oils; canola, palm kernel, palm oil; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/usda-2266214 |
| 67 | Land O'Lakes Honey Butter Spread | 53 | not recorded | not recorded | 9 | Lists seed oils; canola oil; guar gum; sweetened (sugar, honey) | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/catalog-landolakes-honey-butter-spread |
| 68 | Country Crock 35% Vegetable Oil Spread | 47 | not recorded | 100 mg | 14 | Lists seed oils and artificial preservatives; soybean, palm oil; xanthan gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/usda-2285908 |
| 69 | Country Crock Calcium Shedd's Spread | 47 | not recorded | 100 mg | 14 | Lists seed oils and artificial preservatives; soybean, palm oil; xanthan gum; no sweetener | https://cleanfoodscore.com/product/usda-2614784 |

Not scored (no current complete label on record, so neither clean nor flagged): Truly Grass Fed Salted Butter; 4th & Heart Ghee Butter Sticks: Unsalted; Truly Grass Fed Unsalted Butter; 4th & Heart Ghee Butter Sticks: Salted; Pure Indian Foods Cultured Ghee; 4th & Heart Turmeric Ghee; 4th & Heart Vanilla Bean Ghee; 4th & Heart Original Ghee; Cabot Creamery Whipped Salted; Cabot Creamery Unsalted Butter; Cabot Creamery Salted Butter; Cabot Creamery Extra Creamy Unsalted Butter; Cabot Creamery Extra Creamy Sea Salted Butter; Vital Farms Salted Butter; Straus Family Creamery Organic Lightly Salted European Style Butter; Straus Family Creamery Organic Unsalted European Style Butter; Tillamook Extra Creamy Salted Butter; Tillamook Extra Creamy Unsalted Butter; Kerrygold Irish Butter with Olive Oil; Land O'Lakes Garlic & Herb Butter Spread; Sierra Nevada Cheese Co. Organic Vat Cultured Euro Style Butter, Unsalted; Sierra Nevada Cheese Co. Organic Vat Cultured Euro Style Butter, Salted.

## What to verify on the label

Organic and grass-fed are separate claims. Check for both on the exact package if both matter to you. Choose the exact variant: salted, unsalted, sticks, or a spread with added oils. Local prices vary. Match the Amazon listing to the exact variant and compare the same net weight.

## A website logo is not enough

A brand can sell several dairy lines. Look for the claim on the exact product page and package, rather than taking a general brand logo as proof. The Organic Valley butter comparison is linked to its specific salted butter listing.

Source: [Organic Valley: salted butter](https://www.organicvalley.coop/products/salted-butter)

## Ingredients are a separate comparison

A grass-fed or organic claim does not answer whether a spread contains added oil. Compare the saved label against your avoid list, then match the salted or unsalted block, sticks, or spread at the store.

## Your preferences, explained

The clean score is strict and needs no setup: nine additive groups not found in a current ingredient statement, plus a verified organic claim (and a grass-fed or pasture-raised claim for animal foods), are needed for 100; a possible match earns half and a missing claim earns nothing. Missing or expired evidence stays unknown. It does not assess nutrition, allergies, contaminants, or safety.

## Questions

### What should I compare when choosing butter?

Salted or unsalted: Match the butter style your recipe calls for. Butter or blend: Read cream, cultures and any oils in spreadable or flavored versions. Sourcing claims: Review organic and grass-fed claims separately and check the supporting source. Amount and price: Compare package weights and how much you will use.

### Is organic butter always grass-fed?

These are separate claims. Our Organic Valley record supports organic and pasture-raised milk claims; we have not verified a 100% grass-fed claim for that specific butter.

### Do you have a verified organic and grass-fed butter?

Use both claim filters to find products with separately reviewed organic and grass-fed claims. Missing claims stay unverified; an organic claim alone does not establish grass-fed sourcing.

### Why is there no butter price per ounce?

We have not verified a current retailer price for these exact packages. Find a store and compare its price against the package weight.

### Are these Amazon prices live?

We do not display live Amazon prices. Use Buy on Amazon to open a reviewed product listing and check its package, seller and current price. Stock and delivery depend on your location. If an exact listing is not confirmed, Find where to buy opens the official product source.

### Why does a product have no score?

We withhold scores when the complete ingredient evidence is missing or expired, or when you have not selected any additive groups. A manufacturer product page or an Amazon listing alone does not verify an ingredient label.

## Sources

- [USDA Agricultural Marketing Service: Butter grades and standards](https://www.ams.usda.gov/grades-standards/butter-grades-and-standards)
- [USDA Agricultural Marketing Service: Organic labeling and what the USDA Organic seal means](https://www.ams.usda.gov/rules-regulations/organic/labeling)
- [American Grassfed Association: AGA grass-fed standards](https://www.americangrassfed.org/about-us/our-standards/)
- [Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health: Dairy](https://nutritionsource.hsph.harvard.edu/food-features/dairy/)
- [American Heart Association: Saturated fats](https://www.heart.org/en/healthy-living/healthy-eating/eat-smart/fats/saturated-fats)

## Method

Clean score: a 0 to 100 score of the ingredient label only (60 points for nine additive groups not listed: seed oils, artificial dyes, MSG, artificial sweeteners, carrageenan, artificial preservatives, hydrogenated oils, corn syrups, additives banned abroad; 25 for a confirmed organic claim; 15 for a confirmed grass-fed or pasture-raised claim on animal foods). It is not a nutrition, allergy or safety rating. Labels come from the maker’s own page or the USDA FoodData Central branded record, are copied verbatim, and count for 90 days from the check date. Equal scores are ordered by the label: no sweetener first, then less added sugar per serving, then the shorter ingredient list.
