CleanFoodScore Standards & Methodology
CleanFoodScore was founded to bring transparency to packaged groceries and restaurant menus. Every verdict comes from a recorded ingredient label, no manufacturer sponsors a result, and the Amazon buying links that fund the site never change a score or ranking.
Last reviewed
The 90-Day Freshness Rule
Brands reformulate ingredients quietly. A verified record on CleanFoodScore is strictly valid for 90 days from its fixed verification date. When 90 days lapse without manual re-audit, the verdict automatically returns Unknown and cannot be recommended as a clean alternative.
Primary Source Verification
We only accept full, official ingredient statements directly from the brand's product packaging or verified manufacturer nutrition documentation, or the brand-submitted label records in USDA FoodData Central. For supplements we also use the NIH Dietary Supplement Label Database, where the Office of Dietary Supplements photographs and transcribes labels as sold; we use only on-market labels entered since 2020, and each product page shows the date the label was photographed. A supplement earns the organic points only when its label carries the USDA Organic seal or names its organic certifier for the product; “made with organic …” labels (the 70% category) and seals beside a single ingredient do not count. Generic homepage links or marketing buzzwords ("all natural") are categorically rejected.
Inclusion Policy
Each comparison lists products from makers' own online stores plus a curated set of about 10 to 20 well-known national supermarket brands and up to 8 supermarket store brands (such as Great Value, Kroger and Simple Truth, Kirkland Signature, 365 by Whole Foods Market, Trader Joe's, Good & Gather, O Organics, Signature Select, Publix and H-E-B). Store brands are included like any other brand. Mainstream and store-brand products come from USDA FoodData Central Branded Foods (public domain, CC0): we keep the most recent US record with an ingredient statement, remove duplicate sizes and variants, copy the ingredients and nutrition exactly as listed, and show the FDC ID and data date. A field missing from the record stays Unknown. These products are scored with the same rules as every other product. We add no photos, prices or Amazon links to them, and we never copy scores or data from other rating sites or retailers.
Regional Ingredient Specificity
A product sold in the United States may contain artificial colorings and preservatives that are banned or voluntarily substituted in Australia or the EU. Every record is strictly tied to its geographic region and recipe code.
Verified vs. User Evidence
Our database clearly distinguishes between independently verified manufacturer records and user-pasted package labels. Pasted labels run through identical matching logic, but are labeled as user-supplied evidence.
Diet-fit labels
The optional diet-fit columns in every comparison table read the recorded label against one plain rule each. Each cell says Fits, Doesn't fit or Unknown. Unknown means the label or nutrition data we need is missing or older than 90 days; it is never a pass. This is not medical advice. These labels do not say a food is safe, healthy or suitable for any person or condition. Ask your doctor or a registered dietitian about your own diet.
Keto-friendly
Rule: Fits when the recorded nutrition panel shows 5 g or less of net carbs per serving (total carbohydrate minus dietary fiber). Doesn't fit above 5 g. Unknown when no nutrition panel is recorded. Nutrition panels currently come from USDA FoodData Central label records for the national brands in each comparison, scaled from FDC's per-100 g values to the label serving size; other products show Unknown. We never estimate carbs from a product name or ingredient list. The 5 g per-serving line is our own threshold, chosen because keto diets keep total carbohydrate to roughly 20–50 g a day and keto-labeled breads carry about 0–5 g net carbs.
Sources: Cleveland Clinic, Ketosis (under 50 g of carbohydrates a day); Mass General Brigham, Keto diet for epilepsy (about 20–50 g a day; keto-labeled breads 0–5 g net carb; definition of net carb).
Reflux triggers (common GERD triggers)
Rule: Shown as the Reflux triggers check under Nutrition & label checks. None found (green check, under the No reflux triggers column) when a current ingredient list names none of these common reflux triggers: caffeine or coffee; chocolate or cocoa; mint or peppermint; citrus fruit (lemon, lime, orange, grapefruit); tomato; chili, hot peppers and black, white or cayenne pepper; added alcohol (wine, beer, sake, mirin or liquor, or alcohol listed as its own ingredient); carbonation. Listed when any is, with the matched words shown. Unknown without a current ingredient list. Citric acid is not counted as citrus. Alcohol that appears only inside a vanilla or other extract or flavoring, or inside soy sauce, tamari or miso (for example “vanilla extract (alcohol, vanilla)”, or the alcohol a tamari or miso adds to preserve freshness), is not counted, nor is “bourbon vanilla” (a vanilla variety) or syrup aged in spirit barrels. Triggers differ from person to person, and fat content, portion size and meal timing also matter; this check does not measure them and does not mean a food is safe for GERD.
Sources: Johns Hopkins Medicine, GERD diet (chili powder and pepper, tomato-based sauces, citrus fruits, chocolate, peppermint, carbonated beverages); Mayo Clinic, GERD diagnosis and treatment (common triggers include alcohol, chocolate, caffeine, fatty foods and peppermint).
Kids-friendly label
Rule: Fits when a current ingredient list names no added sugar (sugar, honey, syrups, molasses, dextrose, fructose, glucose, cane juice, agave, juice concentrate and similar), no caffeine or coffee, and no artificial food dye. Doesn't fit when any is listed. When a nutrition panel is recorded, sodium above 140 mg per serving (the FDA “low sodium” line) also doesn't fit; today that covers the national brands with a USDA FoodData Central label record. Unknown without a current ingredient list, or when a dye is only possible. The added-sugar and caffeine checks follow guidance for children under 2; honey should not be given before 12 months. This column does not assess nutrition, allergens, choking risk or portion size.
Sources: CDC, Foods and drinks to avoid or limit (no added sugars for infants and young children, no honey before 12 months, avoid caffeinated drinks under 24 months, avoid high-sodium foods); American Academy of Pediatrics, Food Additives and Child Health (technical report, 2018) (artificial food colors and children's behavior; calls for FDA reassessment); FDA, Sodium in your diet (“low sodium” means 140 mg or less per serving).
Personal care checks
Shampoo, deodorant, sunscreen, body care and toothpaste are scored on their own checks. Food checks (seed oils, MSG, sweeteners, organic and sourcing claims) never apply to them. Every check reads only the product's recorded ingredient list, copied from the maker's own product page (for sunscreen, the Drug Facts active and inactive ingredients). A check says what the label lists; it is not a safety, allergy or performance rating, and it does not test SPF or odor protection. A missing or expired label is Unknown.
Score: each scored check is worth an equal share of 100. Every personal-care product is scored on six shared checks (fragrance, sulfates, parabens, harsh preservatives, drying alcohol, added colors) plus one for its type: aluminum for deodorant, UV filters for sunscreen, silicones for hair care. Body care and toothpaste use the six shared checks.
Fragrance-free
Rule: Listed when the ingredient list names fragrance, parfum or aroma. Essential oils are a separate, optional check. Why people check it: fragrance is one of the most common causes of cosmetic contact allergy, and US labels may list a fragrance blend as the single word “fragrance.”
Source: FDA, Fragrances in cosmetics.
No sulfates
Rule: Listed when the list names sodium or ammonium lauryl sulfate, sodium laureth sulfate, sodium coco-sulfate or a similar sulfate cleanser. Sulfonates and isethionates (for example sodium C14-16 olefin sulfonate, sodium cocoyl isethionate) are different cleansers and are not counted. Why people check it: shoppers with dry, color-treated or curly hair often look for sulfate-free cleansers. This is a cleansing-strength preference, not a safety finding.
No parabens
Rule: Listed when the list names any paraben (methylparaben, propylparaben, butylparaben and others). Why people check it: parabens are widely used preservatives that many shoppers choose to avoid; FDA states it has no information showing that parabens as used in cosmetics affect health.
Source: FDA, Parabens in cosmetics.
No harsh preservatives
Rule: Listed when the list names a formaldehyde-releasing preservative (DMDM hydantoin, quaternium-15, imidazolidinyl urea, diazolidinyl urea, bronopol, sodium hydroxymethylglycinate, methenamine) or methylisothiazolinone / methylchloroisothiazolinone (MI/MCI). Why people check it: these are well-known skin sensitizers. The EU bans MI in leave-on cosmetics and requires a “releases formaldehyde” warning on products that release it above a set level.
Sources: EU Regulation 2016/1198 (MI in leave-on products); EU Regulation 2022/1181 (formaldehyde labelling); FDA, Products that release formaldehyde.
No drying alcohol
Rule: Listed when the list names alcohol on its own, alcohol denat., SD alcohol, ethanol or isopropyl alcohol. Fatty alcohols (cetyl, stearyl, cetearyl, behenyl) and benzyl alcohol are different ingredients and are not counted. Why people check it: shoppers with dry or sensitive skin and scalp often avoid short-chain alcohols, which evaporate quickly. This is a preference, not a safety finding.
No added colors
Rule: Listed when the list names an FD&C or D&C color, a color lake, or a CI color index number (for example CI 77491 iron oxides in a tinted sunscreen). Why people check it: the same reason as the food dye check; colors in cosmetics must be FDA-listed color additives.
Source: 21 CFR Part 74, listing of color additives subject to certification.
Aluminum-free (deodorant only)
Rule: Listed when the list names an aluminum antiperspirant salt (aluminum chlorohydrate, aluminum zirconium compounds, aluminum chloride and similar). These are the active ingredients that make a product an antiperspirant rather than a deodorant.
Mineral filters only (sunscreen only)
Rule: Passes when the only UV filters listed are zinc oxide or titanium dioxide; listed when it names avobenzone, oxybenzone, octinoxate, homosalate, octisalate, octocrylene or another chemical filter. Why people check it: in 2019 FDA proposed that only zinc oxide and titanium dioxide be recognized as generally safe and effective, and asked manufacturers for more data on the other filters. That proposal is not a finding that the other filters are unsafe.
Source: FDA proposed rule, Sunscreen drug products for over-the-counter human use (2019).
Silicone-free (hair care only)
Rule: Listed when the list names a silicone: dimethicone, amodimethicone or any other -methicone, cyclopentasiloxane or another -siloxane. Why people check it: many people with curly hair follow silicone-free routines. This is a styling preference, not a safety finding.
Optional columns (not scored)
EU-listed fragrance allergens: listed when the list names one of the fragrance allergens the EU requires on cosmetic labels (linalool, limonene, citral, geraniol, citronellol, eugenol and others). PEG and ethoxylated ingredients: listed for PEG- and PPG- ingredients, -eth ingredients (laureth, ceteareth, steareth) and polysorbates, which can carry traces of 1,4-dioxane from manufacturing. Essential oils: listed for named essential oils such as lavender, tea tree, peppermint and eucalyptus.
Sources: EU Regulation 2023/1545 (fragrance allergen labelling); FDA, 1,4-Dioxane in cosmetics.
Nutrition & label checks
These optional comparison-table columns report what a product's recorded label lists or states. Pick up to three at a time. Ingredient checks are phrased like the other Ingredient checks say None listed, Listed (with the matched words) or Unknownldquo;No Ingredient checks say None listed, Listed (with the matched words) or Unknownhellip;Ingredient checks say None listed, Listed (with the matched words) or Unknownrdquo; columns (No reflux triggers, No high-FODMAP, No added sugar) and say None found with a green check, Listed with a red cross (and the matched words) or Unknown; sodium and fiber show the amount per serving and its % Daily Value. Unknown means the ingredient list is missing or older than 90 days, or no Nutrition Facts panel is recorded; it is never a pass. Nutrition panels currently come from USDA FoodData Central label records, scaled to the label serving, so sodium and fiber are turned off on shelves where fewer than one in five products have one. People often look at these for acid reflux or a bland diet (reflux triggers), IBS or bloating (FODMAPs), blood sugar (added sugar), blood pressure (sodium) and constipation (fiber), but a label reading cannot say whether a food suits you. This is not medical advice. Ask your doctor or a registered dietitian.
High-FODMAP ingredients
Rule: Listed when a current ingredient list names an ingredient on Monash University's list of high-FODMAP ingredients to look for on food labels: honey, agave, high-fructose corn syrup, fructose or fruit sugar, apple or pear juice and fruit juice concentrate, dried fruit (such as raisins, dates and prunes); lactose; the polyols sorbitol, mannitol, xylitol, isomalt, maltitol, lactitol and erythritol; garlic, onion, inulin, fructans, FOS and chicory root; and wheat or rye when it is the first ingredient. Otherwise None found. Amounts are not on ingredient lists, so this cannot tell how much of an ingredient a serving holds, and None found does not mean a product has been FODMAP tested. Products certified through a FODMAP testing program are the reliable way to know.
Sources: Monash University, Food processing and FODMAPs (Table 1, high FODMAP ingredients to look for on food labels); Monash University, Label reading and FODMAPs.
Added sugar
Rule: Listed when a current ingredient list names an added sugar (sugar of any kind, honey, syrups such as corn, rice, maple or agave, molasses, dextrose, fructose, glucose, cane juice, nectars, and sweetening fruit juice concentrates), or when the recorded Nutrition Facts panel shows more than 0 g of added sugars. When the panel is recorded, the grams of added sugars per serving show under the pill. Fiber syrups, allulose and sugar alcohols are not counted, nor are lemon or lime juice and vegetable juice used for color. Otherwise None found.
Sources: FDA, Added sugars on the Nutrition Facts label; FDA, Daily Value on the Nutrition and Supplement Facts labels.
Sodium
Rule: The sodium per serving from the recorded Nutrition Facts panel and its % Daily Value, using FDA's Daily Value of 2,300 mg. A “Low sodium” note shows at 140 mg or less per serving, FDA's level for a “low sodium” claim. FDA measures that claim per reference amount, which can differ from the label serving, so the note is a reading of the panel, not the maker's claim. Unknown without a recorded panel.
Sources: FDA, Daily Value on the Nutrition and Supplement Facts labels (sodium 2,300 mg); FDA, Sodium in your diet (“low sodium” means 140 mg or less per serving); 21 CFR 101.61.
Fiber
Rule: The dietary fiber per serving from the recorded Nutrition Facts panel and its % Daily Value, using FDA's Daily Value of 28 g. A “Good source” note shows at 10–19% of the Daily Value per serving and “Excellent source” at 20% or more, FDA's levels for those claims (FDA measures them per reference amount). Unknown without a recorded panel.
Sources: FDA, Daily Value on the Nutrition and Supplement Facts labels (dietary fiber 28 g); 21 CFR 101.54 (“good source” 10–19%, “high” or “excellent source” 20% or more).
Editorial independence and how we are funded
CleanFoodScore is free to use. Some product pages and guides include “Buy on Amazon” links, and as an Amazon Associate we earn a commission from qualifying purchases made through them (tracking ID cleanfoodscore-20). Those links never change a product's score, verdict or position in a list. Products without an Amazon link are scored and ranked by exactly the same rules.
We do not accept sponsored listings, paid placements or paid reviews, and a brand cannot pay to change a result. The matching rules are deterministic and apply identically to every brand:
- Definite statements take precedence: An explicit ingredient match always supersedes a conditional ("may contain") allergen statement.
- Multi-representation aliases: We recognize synonym variations including E-numbers, INS codes, FD&C numbers with '#' or 'No.', and chemical designations.
- Clean Verdict: A product receives a Clean verdict only when no selected additive is detected in its verified statement.
Notice a Recipe Formulation Change?
Brands change recipes. If the label on your package differs from the one we recorded, paste it into the label checker to see your result straight away. Product pages show the label source and the date we checked it, so you can compare it with your package.
Report a label problem: contact@cleanfoodscore.com