← Compare another category

Seafood · Product label guide

Sardines vs anchovies: 24 tins compared label by label, plus every canned fish ranked.

Updated

Quick answer

Both are small, oily fish sold in tins, and the FDA and EPA list both among the best choices for eating fish. On the label the big difference is salt: anchovy fillets are salt-cured before they are packed, so the anchovy records we hold run about 5,733 mg of sodium per 100 g against 367 mg for sardines (medians), and they are eaten a few fillets at a time. Of the 15 sardine labels we hold, 7 are packed in olive oil; the tables below show what every tin is packed in and rank the best sardines by label.

FDA and EPA: advice about eating fish (best choices include anchovy, herring, salmon and sardine)

Picks by need · 72 current labels, checked through 2026-11-14

Best canned fish by what you want

  1. Top label score

    Bumble BeePink Salmon100

    100/100. 2 ingredients, no added oil, no sweetener listed, none of the 9 additive groups we check.

  2. Best unsweetened

    Crown PrinceSmoked Kipper Snacks100

    100/100. No sugar or other sweetener on the label.

  3. No added oil or gum

    King OscarWater Sardines100

    100/100. 2 ingredients, none of them an oil, gum or carrageenan.

  4. Lowest sodium

    StarKistLow Sodium Albacore White Tuna100

    70 mg sodium per 74 g (2.6 onz); 100/100.

Most flagged: Chicken of the Sea Wild Caught Sardines in Oil lists seed oils (89/100); Chicken of the Sea Chunk Light Tuna Il Oil lists seed oils (89/100); Chicken of the Sea Chunk Light Tuna in Oil lists seed oils (89/100).

A 0 to 100 label score, not a nutrition rating: 60 points for nine additive groups not on the label, 25 for a confirmed organic claim.

From the catalog

Sardines vs anchovies: the labels side by side

Counted from the current labels on our canned fish shelf whose names say sardines (including brisling and pilchards) or anchovies. Sodium is per 100 g from each product’s USDA FoodData Central record, so tins with different serving sizes compare fairly; anchovy servings are much smaller, often one 15 g portion of a few fillets.

Sardines vs anchovies: what 15 sardine and 9 anchovy labels list (current labels, counted at the last site build)
SardinesAnchovies
Current labels we hold159
Packed in olive oil7 of 158 of 9
Packed in a seed oil (soybean, sunflower, canola)1 of 150 of 9
Packed in water only7 of 151 of 9
Salt listed13 of 159 of 9
Smoked or smoke flavor6 of 150 of 9
Median sodium per 100 g (USDA records)367 mg (10 records)5,733 mg (6 records)
Median label serving (USDA records)85 g15 g
FDA and EPA: advice about eating fish (best choices include anchovy, herring, salmon and sardine)

From the catalog

Best sardines: all 15 sardine labels ranked

Equal scores are ordered by what the label shows: no sweetener first, then less added sugar per serving, then the shorter ingredient list. The score is a 0 to 100 label score (60 points for nine additive groups not found, up to 25 for a verified organic claim, up to 15 for a verified grass-fed or pasture-raised claim on animal foods); it is not a health or nutrition rating. Sugar and sodium per serving come from the product’s USDA FoodData Central Branded Foods record (per-100 g values scaled to the label serving, so they can differ by rounding from the printed panel); a dash means the label we hold came from the maker’s site without a recorded nutrition panel.

15 sardine labels ranked by Clean Food Score
RankProductScorePacked inSodium per servingGroups flagged
1King Oscar Water Sardines100Water130 mgNone
2Bumble Bee Brisling Sardines in Water100Water150 mgNone
3King Oscar Brisling Sardines in Extra Virgin Olive Oil100Extra virgin olive oil350 mgNone
4Season Sardines in 100% Olive Oil100Olive oil340 mgNone
5Season Sardines in Water100Water340 mgNone
6Goya Premium Sardines in Olive Oil100Olive oil280 mgNone
7Wild Planet Wild Sardines in Water No Salt Added100Water–None
8Brunswick Sardines in Olive Oil100Olive oil290 mgNone
9Chicken of the Sea Sardines in Water100Water240 mgNone
10Crown Prince Skinless & Boneless Sardines in Water100Water180 mgNone
11Wild Planet Wild Sardines Skinless & Boneless Fillets in Extra Virgin Olive Oil100Extra virgin olive oil–None
12Wild Planet Wild Sardines Skinless & Boneless Fillets in Water100Water–None
13Wild Planet Wild Sardines in Extra Virgin Olive Oil100Extra virgin olive oil–None
14Wild Planet Wild Sardines in Extra Virgin Olive Oil with Lemon100Extra virgin olive oil–None
15Chicken of the Sea Wild Caught Sardines in Oil89Soybean oil270 mgSeed Oils

From the catalog

Anchovies: all 9 labels ranked

Anchovy fillets are salt-cured before they are packed, and 9 of 9 anchovy labels list salt. Ranked by Clean Food Score with what each is packed in.

9 anchovy labels ranked by Clean Food Score
RankProductScorePacked inSodium per servingGroups flagged
1Sea Tales Anchovy Fillets in Olive Oil100Olive oil685 mgNone
2Bellino Flat Fillets of Anchovies in Olive Oil100Olive oil960 mgNone
3Cento Flat Fillet Anchovies in Olive Oil100Olive oil860 mgNone
4Season Flat Fillets of Anchovies in 100% Olive Oil100Olive oil860 mgNone
5Crown Prince Flat Anchovies in Olive Oil100Olive oil860 mgNone
6Fishwife Cantabrian Anchovies in Extra Virgin Olive Oil100Extra virgin olive oil–None
7Wild Planet Wild White Anchovies in Water100Water–None
8Napoleon Rolled Anchovies with Capers100Olive oil920 mgNone
9Wild Planet Wild White Anchovies in Extra Virgin Olive Oil100Extra virgin olive oil–None

Compare the recorded labels

Find the ingredients that matter to you.

This table holds the 12 highest-scoring of the 93 canned fish we track. See all 93 on the shelf page, including products we cannot score until a current label is on record.

12 of 12 products

“No …” columns: None found on the label · Listed on the label · Unknown. Diet fit: Fits · Doesn’t fit · Unknown (rules; not medical advice). Claims: verified · not established. Default: most check marks first; not a health score.

Compare product claims and recorded ingredients. Click a column heading to sort.
Buy
100 / 1009 of 9 groups clear · organic not applicableProduct details →4
100 / 1009 of 9 groups clear · organic not applicableProduct details →4
100 / 1009 of 9 groups clear · organic not applicableProduct details →4
100 / 1009 of 9 groups clear · organic not applicableProduct details →4
100 / 1009 of 9 groups clear · organic not applicableProduct details →4
100 / 1009 of 9 groups clear · organic not applicableProduct details →4
100 / 1009 of 9 groups clear · organic not applicableFind where to buy ↗Product details →4
100 / 1009 of 9 groups clear · organic not applicableProduct details →4
100 / 1009 of 9 groups clear · organic not applicableProduct details →4
100 / 1009 of 9 groups clear · organic not applicableFind where to buy ↗Product details →4
100 / 1009 of 9 groups clear · organic not applicableProduct details →4
100 / 1009 of 9 groups clear · organic not applicableProduct details →4
How the clean score works

No setup needed, and strict: a full 100 needs every additive group clear and a verified organic claim (animal foods also need a verified grass-fed or pasture-raised claim; wild seafood and salt, which have no USDA organic standard, are scored without the organic points, and plant-based milks, cheeses and proteins without the feeding claim). Points: the nine additive groups (seed oils, artificial dyes, MSG, artificial sweeteners, carrageenan, artificial preservatives, hydrogenated oils, corn syrups, banned-abroad additives) share 60 points equally — not found earns a group’s full share, “may contain” earns half, listed earns 0; a verified organic claim is worth 25; a verified grass-fed or pasture-raised claim is worth 15 and counts only for animal foods. No claim, or an expired or unverified claim, earns nothing, so products without those claims cannot reach 100. Unverified or expired ingredient labels receive no score. Equal scores are equal. Equal scores are ordered by the label: no sweetener first, then less added sugar per serving, then the shorter ingredient list. Unknown and stale evidence never passes “Only show matches.” Producer claims and prices do not affect this score. This is not a nutrition, allergy, or safety rating.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Buying links do not influence ingredient results. “Buy on Amazon” opens a reviewed product listing; “Find where to buy” opens the maker’s page. Confirm the package, seller, stock, and current price before checkout. Price observations expire after 30 days.

The full guide · Seafood

Choosing canned fish: what to check before you buy

Compare the exact fish species, packing liquid and drained portion. Tuna, salmon, sardines and other canned seafood differ in flavor and how you use them, while sauces and added oils change the recipe.

Check sodium and whether nutrition is stated for drained fish or the full contents. For mercury-related choices, use the FDA/EPA fish guidance linked below; the ingredient check does not measure mercury in a can.

What to compare

Exact species
Read the species rather than treating every tuna or seafood product as the same.
Packing and drained amount
Compare water, oil or sauce and the portion you will eat.
Sodium
Check the same serving amount and whether the panel is for drained contents.
Mercury and sourcing
Use the FDA/EPA species guidance for mercury questions and fishery details for sourcing.

Your preferences, explained

The clean score is strict and needs no setup: nine additive groups not found in a current ingredient statement, plus a verified organic claim (and a grass-fed or pasture-raised claim for animal foods), are needed for 100; a possible match earns half and a missing claim earns nothing. Missing or expired evidence stays unknown. It does not assess nutrition, allergies, contaminants, or safety.

References

  1. Advice about eating fish U.S. Food and Drug Administration
  2. Omega-3 fatty acids fact sheet for consumers NIH Office of Dietary Supplements
  3. Fish Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health
  4. Seafood Watch recommendations Monterey Bay Aquarium
  5. MSC certified sustainable seafood Marine Stewardship Council

An ingredient check is not a nutrition, contaminant, allergy or safety assessment. How we verify labels →