← Compare another category

Dairy & eggs · Product label guide

Butter: compare ingredients, then choose.

Updated

Compare salted, unsalted, cultured and spreadable butter by recipe and cooking use. Review organic and grass-fed as separate sourcing claims.

Picks by need · 69 current labels, checked through 2026-11-21

Best butter by what you want

Of the 69 butter we can score by label, 60 list none of the nine additive groups we check. The top label is Organic Valley Organic Salted Butter (100/100); for best non-organic, Kerrygold Pure Irish Butter, Salted. The additive group listed most often on this shelf is seed oils (9 labels).

  1. Top label score

    Organic ValleyOrganic Salted Butter100

    100/100. 2 ingredients, no added oil, no sweetener listed, none of the 9 additive groups we check. Includes 25 points for a confirmed organic claim.

    Buy on Amazon ↗
  2. Best non-organic

    KerrygoldPure Irish Butter, Salted75

    75/100, the top score possible without an organic claim. 2 ingredients, no added oil, no sweetener listed, none of the 9 additive groups we check.

    Buy on Amazon ↗
  3. Best unsweetened

    Clover SonomaOrganic Salted Butter85

    85/100. No sugar or other sweetener on the label.

    Find where to buy ↗
  4. No added oil or gum

    Nancy'sOrganic Unsalted Butter85

    85/100. 2 ingredients, none of them an oil, gum or carrageenan.

    Find where to buy ↗

Most flagged: Country Crock 35% Vegetable Oil Spread lists seed oils and artificial preservatives (47/100); Country Crock Calcium Shedd's Spread lists seed oils and artificial preservatives (47/100); 4th & Heart Ghee Spray lists seed oils (53/100).

A 0 to 100 label score, not a nutrition rating: 60 points for nine additive groups not on the label, 25 for a confirmed organic claim, 15 for a confirmed grass-fed or pasture-raised claim on animal foods.

Compare the recorded labels

Find the ingredients that matter to you.

How the clean score works

No setup needed, and strict: a full 100 needs every additive group clear and a verified organic claim (animal foods also need a verified grass-fed or pasture-raised claim; wild seafood and salt, which have no USDA organic standard, are scored without the organic points, and plant-based milks, cheeses and proteins without the feeding claim). Points: the nine additive groups (seed oils, artificial dyes, MSG, artificial sweeteners, carrageenan, artificial preservatives, hydrogenated oils, corn syrups, banned-abroad additives) share 60 points equally — not found earns a group’s full share, “may contain” earns half, listed earns 0; a verified organic claim is worth 25; a verified grass-fed or pasture-raised claim is worth 15 and counts only for animal foods. No claim, or an expired or unverified claim, earns nothing, so products without those claims cannot reach 100. Unverified or expired ingredient labels receive no score. Equal scores are equal. Equal scores are ordered by the label: no sweetener first, then less added sugar per serving, then the shorter ingredient list. Unknown and stale evidence never passes “Only show matches.” Producer claims and prices do not affect this score. This is not a nutrition, allergy, or safety rating.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Buying links do not influence ingredient results. “Buy on Amazon” opens a reviewed product listing; “Find where to buy” opens the maker’s page. Confirm the package, seller, stock, and current price before checkout. Price observations expire after 30 days.

Full ranking

Butter ranked: 69 labels

Every butter label with a current, complete ingredient list, ranked by clean score. Equal scores are ordered by what the label shows: no sweetener first, then less added sugar per serving, then the shorter ingredient list. Added sugar is per serving, from the nutrition panel when we recorded one. 22 more products have no current label on record, so they are not ranked; they are in the filter tool below.

Show the full ranking as a plain table
69 butter labels ranked by clean score (0 to 100, label only; not a nutrition rating)
RankProductScoreAdded sugarIngredientsWhy it ranks here
1Organic Valley Organic Salted Butter100–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener; organic claim +25; grass-fed/pasture claim +15
2Clover Sonoma Organic Salted Butter85–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener; organic claim +25
3Nancy's Organic Unsalted Butter85–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener; organic claim +25
4Organic Valley Organic Unsalted Butter85–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener; organic claim +25
5Clover Sonoma Organic Unsalted Butter85–3No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener; organic claim +25
6Nancy's Organic Sea Salted Butter85–3No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener; organic claim +25
7Organic Valley Organic Butter with Olive Oil85–4No flagged additive; olive oil; no sweetener; organic claim +25
8Kerrygold Pure Irish Butter, Salted75–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener; grass-fed/pasture claim +15
9Maple Hill Salted Butter75–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener; grass-fed/pasture claim +15
10Maple Hill Unsalted Butter75–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener; grass-fed/pasture claim +15
11Good & Gather Salted Butter600 g2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
12Kirkland Signature Salted Sweet Cream Butter600 g2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
13Land O Lakes Salted Butter Balls60–1No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
14365 by Whole Foods Market Salted Butter60–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
154th & Heart Garlic Ghee60–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
164th & Heart Himalayan Pink Salt Ghee60–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
17Breakstone's All Natural Salted Butter60–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
18Challenge Butter60–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
19Challenge Butter European Style Butter60–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
20Challenge Butter Salted Butter60–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
21Challenge Butter Unsalted Butter60–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
22Challenge Butter Whipped Butter60–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
23Clover Sonoma European Salted Butter60–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
24Clover Sonoma Sweet Cream Salted Butter60–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
25Great Value Butter Salted Sticks60–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
26GreenWise Unsalted Butter60–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
27Kate's Sea Salted Butter60–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
28Kate's Sea Salted ButterCup60–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
29Kerrygold High Heat Cooking Butter60–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
30Kerrygold Naturally Softer Irish Butter60–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
31Kerrygold Pure Irish Butter Sticks60–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
32Kroger Salted Butter60–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
33Land O Lakes Salted Butter60–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
34Land O Lakes Unsalted Butter60–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
35Land O Lakes Whipped Unsalted Butter60–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
36Land O'Lakes Extra Creamy Salted Butter60–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
37Land O'Lakes Salted Butter60–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
38Land O'Lakes Salted Whipped Butter60–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
39Land O'Lakes Unsalted Butter60–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
40Minerva Dairy Sea Salt Butter60–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
41Minerva Dairy Unsalted Butter60–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
42O Organics Salted Sweet Cream Butter60–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
43Publix Unsalted Sweet Cream Butter60–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
44Sierra Nevada Cheese Co. Bella Capra Goat Butter60–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
45Sierra Nevada Cheese Co. Graziers Butter Unsalted60–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
46Sierra Nevada Cheese Co. Natural Unsalted Butter60–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
47Tillamook Salted Sweet Cream Butter60–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
48Tillamook Sweet Cream Butter60–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
49Vermont Creamery Unsalted Cultured Butter60–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
50Clover Sonoma European Unsalted Butter60–3No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
51Clover Sonoma Sweet Cream Unsalted Butter60–3No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
52Kerrygold Unsalted Butter60–3No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
53Plugra Salted Butter60–3No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
54Sierra Nevada Cheese Co. Graziers Butter Salted60–3No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
55Sierra Nevada Cheese Co. Natural Salted Butter60–3No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
56Kerrygold Irish Butter with Avocado Oil60–4No flagged additive; avocado oil; no sweetener
57Land O'Lakes Butter with Olive Oil & Sea Salt60–4No flagged additive; olive oil; no sweetener
58Minerva Dairy Garlic Herb Butter60–5No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
59Plugrá Extra Creamy Butter with Olive Oil and Sea Salt60–5No flagged additive; olive oil; no sweetener
60Kerrygold Garlic & Herb Butter60–8No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
614th & Heart Ghee Spray53–3Lists seed oils; avocado, grapeseed oil; no sweetener
62Challenge Butter Spreadable Butter53–3Lists seed oils; canola oil; no sweetener
63Land O'Lakes Butter with Canola Oil53–3Lists seed oils; canola oil; no sweetener
64Challenge Butter Lactose Free Spreadable Butter53–4Lists seed oils; canola oil; no sweetener
65I Can't Believe It's Not Butter! 28% Vegetable Oil Spread, Light53–10Lists seed oils; soybean, palm oil; no sweetener
66I Can't Believe It's Not Butter! 79% Vegetable Oil Spread Butter53–10Lists seed oils; canola, palm kernel, palm oil; no sweetener
67Land O'Lakes Honey Butter Spread53–9Lists seed oils; canola oil; guar gum; sweetened (sugar, honey)
68Country Crock 35% Vegetable Oil Spread47–14Lists seed oils and artificial preservatives; soybean, palm oil; xanthan gum; no sweetener
69Country Crock Calcium Shedd's Spread47–14Lists seed oils and artificial preservatives; soybean, palm oil; xanthan gum; no sweetener

From the catalog · 4 labels

Land O Lakes butter ingredients

Land O Lakes salted and unsalted butter labels, side by side. Open one to read the recorded ingredient list and its source.

The full guide · Dairy & eggs

Choosing butter: what to check before you buy

For cooking or baking, start with salted versus unsalted butter and the amount your recipe needs. Cultured butter, spreadable blends and flavored butters differ in taste and ingredients; a spread can contain oils alongside cream.

Compare like-sized packages and check the recipe before swapping butter styles. Organic and grass-fed describe sourcing, so review those claims separately from the cream, salt, cultures and any other ingredients listed.

What the labels on this shelf show

We track 91 products from 32 brands on the butter shelf. 69 have a complete, current ingredient label on record (76%), which is what lets us score them. The other 22 stay unscored until the maker publishes a full label; a missing label is “not yet”, never a pass.

Of the 69 scored labels, 60 (87%) list none of the nine additive groups we check. The group that appears most is seed oils, listed on 9 labels, followed by artificial preservatives on 2. 7 scored products carry a verified organic claim, which adds points. Scores here run from 47 to 100, and the typical label lists 2 ingredients.

What to compare

Salted or unsalted
Match the butter style your recipe calls for.
Butter or blend
Read cream, cultures and any oils in spreadable or flavored versions.
Sourcing claims
Review organic and grass-fed claims separately and check the supporting source.
Amount and price
Compare package weights and how much you will use.

What to verify on the label

Organic and grass-fed are separate claims. Check for both on the exact package if both matter to you. Choose the exact variant: salted, unsalted, sticks, or a spread with added oils. Local prices vary. Match the Amazon listing to the exact variant and compare the same net weight.

A website logo is not enough

A brand can sell several dairy lines. Look for the claim on the exact product page and package, rather than taking a general brand logo as proof. The Organic Valley butter comparison is linked to its specific salted butter listing.

Organic Valley: salted butter

Ingredients are a separate comparison

A grass-fed or organic claim does not answer whether a spread contains added oil. Compare the saved label against your avoid list, then match the salted or unsalted block, sticks, or spread at the store.

Your preferences, explained

The clean score is strict and needs no setup: nine additive groups not found in a current ingredient statement, plus a verified organic claim (and a grass-fed or pasture-raised claim for animal foods), are needed for 100; a possible match earns half and a missing claim earns nothing. Missing or expired evidence stays unknown. It does not assess nutrition, allergies, contaminants, or safety.

References

  1. Butter grades and standards USDA Agricultural Marketing Service
  2. Organic labeling and what the USDA Organic seal means USDA Agricultural Marketing Service
  3. AGA grass-fed standards American Grassfed Association
  4. Dairy Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health
  5. Saturated fats American Heart Association

An ingredient check is not a nutrition, contaminant, allergy or safety assessment. How we verify labels →