← Compare another category

Pantry · Product label guide

Nut butters: compare ingredients, then choose.

Updated

Compare almond and peanut butter ingredients, including added oils and sweeteners.

Picks by need · 119 current labels, checked through 2026-11-21

Best nut butters by what you want

Of the 119 nut butters we can score by label, 106 list none of the nine additive groups we check. The top label is Artisana Organics Organic Raw Almond Butter (100/100); for best non-organic, Good & Gather Creamy Almond Butter. The additive group listed most often on this shelf is seed oils (12 labels).

  1. Top label score

    Artisana OrganicsOrganic Raw Almond Butter100

    100/100. 1 ingredient, no added oil, no sweetener listed, none of the 9 additive groups we check. Includes 25 points for a confirmed organic claim.

    Buy on Amazon ↗
  2. Best non-organic

    Good & GatherCreamy Almond Butter71

    71/100, the top score possible without an organic claim. 1 ingredient, no added oil, no sweetener listed, none of the 9 additive groups we check.

  3. Best unsweetened

    Artisana OrganicsOrganic Raw Cashew Butter100

    100/100. No sugar or other sweetener on the label.

    Buy on Amazon ↗
  4. No added oil or gum

    Wilderness PoetsCashew Butter – Raw, Organic100

    100/100. 1 ingredients, none of them an oil, gum or carrageenan.

    Find where to buy ↗

Most flagged: Reese's Spreads, Peanut Butter Chocolate lists seed oils, artificial preservatives and hydrogenated oils (47/100); Signature Select Creamy Peanut Butter lists seed oils and hydrogenated oils (55/100); Great Value Creamy Peanut Butter lists seed oils and hydrogenated oils (55/100).

A 0 to 100 label score, not a nutrition rating: 60 points for nine additive groups not on the label, 25 for a confirmed organic claim.

Compare the recorded labels

Find the ingredients that matter to you.

How the clean score works

No setup needed, and strict: a full 100 needs every additive group clear and a verified organic claim (animal foods also need a verified grass-fed or pasture-raised claim; wild seafood and salt, which have no USDA organic standard, are scored without the organic points, and plant-based milks, cheeses and proteins without the feeding claim). Points: the nine additive groups (seed oils, artificial dyes, MSG, artificial sweeteners, carrageenan, artificial preservatives, hydrogenated oils, corn syrups, banned-abroad additives) share 60 points equally — not found earns a group’s full share, “may contain” earns half, listed earns 0; a verified organic claim is worth 25; a verified grass-fed or pasture-raised claim is worth 15 and counts only for animal foods. No claim, or an expired or unverified claim, earns nothing, so products without those claims cannot reach 100. Unverified or expired ingredient labels receive no score. Equal scores are equal. Equal scores are ordered by the label: no sweetener first, then less added sugar per serving, then the shorter ingredient list. Unknown and stale evidence never passes “Only show matches.” Producer claims and prices do not affect this score. This is not a nutrition, allergy, or safety rating.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Buying links do not influence ingredient results. “Buy on Amazon” opens a reviewed product listing; “Find where to buy” opens the maker’s page. Confirm the package, seller, stock, and current price before checkout. Price observations expire after 30 days.

Full ranking

Nut butters ranked: 119 labels

Every nut butters label with a current, complete ingredient list, ranked by clean score. Equal scores are ordered by what the label shows: no sweetener first, then less added sugar per serving, then the shorter ingredient list. Added sugar is per serving, from the nutrition panel when we recorded one. 19 more products have no current label on record, so they are not ranked; they are in the filter tool below.

Show the full ranking as a plain table
119 nut butters labels ranked by clean score (0 to 100, label only; not a nutrition rating)
RankProductScoreAdded sugarIngredientsWhy it ranks here
1Artisana Organics Organic Raw Almond Butter100–1No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener; organic claim +25
2Artisana Organics Organic Raw Cashew Butter100–1No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener; organic claim +25
3Wilderness Poets Cashew Butter – Raw, Organic100–1No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener; organic claim +25
4Wilderness Poets Cashew Butter – Roasted, Organic100–1No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener; organic claim +25
5Wilderness Poets Extra Crunchy Pistachio Nut Butter – Roasted, Organic100–1No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener; organic claim +25
6Wilderness Poets Pistachio Butter – Ultra Creamy Organic100–1No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener; organic claim +25
7Wilderness Poets Pistachio Nut Butter – Organic, Raw100–1No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener; organic claim +25
8Georgia Grinders Organic Creamy Peanut Butter100–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener; organic claim +25
9Georgia Grinders Organic Crunchy Peanut Butter100–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener; organic claim +25
10MaraNatha Organic Creamy Almond Butter100–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener; organic claim +25
11MaraNatha Organic Crunchy Peanut Butter100–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener; organic claim +25
12Once Again Organic Sesame Tahini100–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener; organic claim +25
13Smucker's Organic Chunky Peanut Butter100–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener; organic claim +25
14Smucker's Organic Creamy Peanut Butter100–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener; organic claim +25
15Tierra Farm Organic Salted Almond Butter100–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener; organic claim +25
16Tierra Farm Organic Salted Cashew Butter100–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener; organic claim +25
17Wilderness Poets Almond Butter – Organic, Raw100–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener; organic claim +25
18Wilderness Poets Hemp Seed Butter – Organic, Raw100–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener; organic claim +25
19Wilderness Poets Pecan Butter with Cashews – Organic, Raw100–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener; organic claim +25
20Wilderness Poets Pine Nut Butter – Organic, Raw100–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener; organic claim +25
21Wilderness Poets Roasted Almond Butter – Organic100–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener; organic claim +25
22Wilderness Poets Walnut Butter with Cashews – Organic, Chandler Variety, California-Grown100–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener; organic claim +25
23Tierra Farm Organic Lightly Sea Salted Mixed Nut Butter100–4No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener; organic claim +25
24Once Again Crunchy Organic Peanut Butter – Unsalted100–6No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener; organic claim +25
25Once Again Creamy Organic Peanut Butter, Unsalted100–7No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener; organic claim +25
26NUTTZO Organic Paleo Power Fuel Crunchy100–8No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener; organic claim +25
27NUTTZO Organic Paleo Power Fuel Smooth100–8No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener; organic claim +25
28NUTTZO Organic Power Fuel Crunchy100–8No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener; organic claim +25
29Tierra Farm Organic Maple Almond Butter100–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; sweetened (maple); organic claim +25
30Tierra Farm Organic Maple Cashew Butter100–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; sweetened (maple); organic claim +25
31Once Again Organic Sunflower Hemp Butter100–3No flagged additive; no oil or gum; sweetened (sugar); organic claim +25
32Tierra Farm Organic Maple Mixed Nut Butter100–4No flagged additive; no oil or gum; sweetened (maple); organic claim +25
33Wilderness Poets Chocolate Hazelnut Butter – Organic100–6No flagged additive; no oil or gum; sweetened (sugar); organic claim +25
34Once Again Organic Sunflower Butter – Lightly Salted & Sweetened – Glass Jar92–3Lists seed oils; sunflower oil; sweetened (sugar); organic claim +25
35Once Again Organic Sunflower Butter – Salt Free, Unsweetened92–3Lists seed oils; sunflower oil; sweetened (sugar); organic claim +25
36Good & Gather Creamy Almond Butter710 g1No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
37365 by Whole Foods Market Creamy Peanut Butter71–1No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
38Crazy Richard's Almond Butter71–1No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
39Crazy Richard's Creamy Peanut Butter71–1No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
40Crazy Richard's Crunchy Peanut Butter71–1No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
41Trader Joe's Raw Almond Butter, Crunchy71–1No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
42Wilderness Poets Macadamia Nut Butter – Raw71–1No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
43Georgia Grinders 6 Resealable Almond Butter Pouches71–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
44Georgia Grinders 6 Resealable Peanut Butter Pouches71–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
45Georgia Grinders Hazelnut Butter71–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
46Georgia Grinders Pecan Butter71–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
47Justin's Classic Almond Butter71–2No flagged additive; palm oil; no sweetener
48Justin's Classic Peanut Butter71–2No flagged additive; palm oil; no sweetener
49Justin's Crunchy Classic Peanut Butter71–2No flagged additive; palm oil; no sweetener
50MaraNatha No Sugar or Salt Added Creamy Almond Butter71–2No flagged additive; palm oil; no sweetener
51MaraNatha Raw Creamy Almond Butter71–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
52Smucker's Natural Chunky Peanut Butter71–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
53Smucker's Natural Creamy Peanut Butter71–2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
54Georgia Grinders Pecan Peanut Butter Blend71–3No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
55Big Spoon Roasters Cashew Butter with Coconut Nectar71–4No flagged additive; coconut oil; no sweetener
56Big Spoon Roasters Crunchy Peanut Butter71–4No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
57Big Spoon Roasters Toasted Coconut Almond Butter71–4No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
58Once Again Creamy Natural Almond Butter – Roasted71–4No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
59Georgia Grinders Chocolate Bourbon Pecan Butter71–5No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
60Georgia Grinders Cinnamon Vanilla Pecan-Peanut Butter Blend71–5No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
61Once Again Creamy Natural Peanut Butter – Salted71–5No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
62Once Again Creamy Natural Peanut Butter – Unsalted71–5No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
63Big Spoon Roasters Lemon Cookie Cashew Butter71–6No flagged additive; coconut oil; no sweetener
64Big Spoon Roasters Lum Lum Thai Curry Peanut & Cashew Butter71–6No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
65Burlap & Barrel Cardamom Bun Almond Butter71–6No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
66NUTTZO Almond Coconut Crunchy71–8No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
67NUTTZO Natural Paleo Power Fuel Crunchy71–8No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
68NUTTZO Natural Paleo Power Fuel Smooth71–8No flagged additive; no oil or gum; no sweetener
69PB2 Powdered Peanut Butter711 g2No flagged additive; no oil or gum; sweetened (sugar)
70O Organics Creamy Peanut Butter Spread711 g4No flagged additive; palm oil; sweetened (sugar)
71Skippy Natural Creamy Peanut Butter Spread712 g4No flagged additive; palm oil; sweetened (sugar)
72Skippy Creamy Peanut Butter Spread713 g4No flagged additive; palm oil; sweetened (sugar)
73Nutella Hazelnut Spread with Cocoa7119 g7No flagged additive; palm oil; sweetened (sugar)
74Jif Natural Creamy Peanut Butter Spread, Honey71–2No flagged additive; palm oil; sweetened (sugar, honey)
75Big Spoon Roasters Almond Butter with Wildflower Honey71–3No flagged additive; no oil or gum; sweetened (honey)
76Big Spoon Roasters Fiji Ginger Almond Butter71–3No flagged additive; no oil or gum; sweetened (sugar)
77Barney Butter Almond Butter Smooth71–4No flagged additive; no oil or gum; sweetened (sugar)
78Big Spoon Roasters Chocolate Sea Salt Almond Butter71–4No flagged additive; no oil or gum; sweetened (sugar, honey)
79Big Spoon Roasters Peanut Butter with Wildflower Honey71–4No flagged additive; coconut oil; sweetened (honey)
80Big Spoon Roasters Peanut Pecan Butter with Wildflower Honey71–4No flagged additive; no oil or gum; sweetened (honey)
81Big Spoon Roasters Pistachio Crunch Almond Butter71–4No flagged additive; no oil or gum; sweetened (maple)
82Crazy Richard's Cinnamon Almond Butter71–4No flagged additive; no oil or gum; sweetened (sugar)
83Justin's Almond Butter, Honey71–4No flagged additive; palm oil; sweetened (sugar, honey)
84Justin's Almond Butter, Maple71–4No flagged additive; palm oil; sweetened (sugar)
85MaraNatha No Stir Creamy Almond Butter71–4No flagged additive; palm oil; sweetened (sugar)
86MaraNatha No Stir Creamy Peanut Butter71–4No flagged additive; palm oil; sweetened (sugar)
87MaraNatha No Stir Crunchy Almond Butter71–4No flagged additive; palm oil; sweetened (sugar)
88Skippy Natural Peanut Butter Spread, Creamy71–4No flagged additive; palm oil; sweetened (sugar)
89SunButter Creamy on the Go SunButter Cups71–4No flagged additive; no oil or gum; sweetened (sugar)
90SunButter Creamy SunButter Tubs71–4No flagged additive; no oil or gum; sweetened (sugar)
91Big Spoon Roasters Maple Cinnamon Peanut & Pecan Butter71–5No flagged additive; no oil or gum; sweetened (maple)
92Jif Natural Peanut Butter Spread, Crunchy71–5No flagged additive; palm oil; sweetened (sugar, molasses)
93MaraNatha Caramel Almond Butter71–5No flagged additive; palm oil; sweetened (sugar)
94MaraNatha Vanilla Almond Butter71–5No flagged additive; palm oil; sweetened (sugar)
95Big Spoon Roasters Eggnog Cashew & Pecan Butter71–6No flagged additive; no oil or gum; sweetened (maple)
96Big Spoon Roasters Sweet Heat Peanut Butter71–6No flagged additive; no oil or gum; sweetened (sugar)
97Big Spoon Roasters Vanilla Caramel Almond & Cashew Butter71–6No flagged additive; no oil or gum; sweetened (maple)
98Big Spoon Roasters Vanilla Latte Almond Butter71–6No flagged additive; coconut oil; sweetened (maple)
99Justin's Honey Peanut Butter71–6No flagged additive; palm, peanut oil; sweetened (sugar, honey)
100Once Again Almond Butter Protein Packets71–6No flagged additive; peanut oil; sweetened (sugar)
101Once Again Sunflower Butter Protein Packets71–6No flagged additive; peanut oil; sweetened (sugar)
102Big Spoon Roasters Bourbon Pecan Peanut Butter71–7No flagged additive; coconut oil; sweetened (sugar, maple)
103Big Spoon Roasters Carrot Cake Almond & Walnut Butter71–8No flagged additive; coconut oil; sweetened (maple)
104NUTTZO Power Fuel Honey71–9No flagged additive; no oil or gum; sweetened (honey)
105Burlap & Barrel Autumn Spice Almond Butter71–10No flagged additive; no oil or gum; sweetened (sugar)
106NUTTZO Chocolate Almond Coconut71–10No flagged additive; no oil or gum; sweetened (monk fruit, erythritol)
107Big Spoon Roasters Chai Spice Peanut & Almond Butter71–11No flagged additive; no oil or gum; sweetened (sugar, honey)
108NUTTZO Pumpkin Spice71–13No flagged additive; no oil or gum; sweetened (sugar)
109Simple Truth Smooth Cashew Butter63–2Lists seed oils; sunflower oil; no sweetener
110Once Again Chocolate Cashew Butter63–5Lists seed oils; sunflower oil; sweetened (sugar)
111Signature Select Creamy Peanut Butter552 g5Lists seed oils and hydrogenated oils; rapeseed, soybean, cottonseed oil; sweetened (sugar, molasses)
112Great Value Creamy Peanut Butter552 g6Lists seed oils and hydrogenated oils; rapeseed, soybean, cottonseed oil; sweetened (sugar, molasses)
113Peter Pan Peanut Butter Twin Pack55–4Lists seed oils and hydrogenated oils; rapeseed, cottonseed oil; sweetened (sugar)
114Skippy Creamy Peanut Butter55–4Lists seed oils and hydrogenated oils; rapeseed, soybean, cottonseed oil; sweetened (sugar)
115Jif Creamy Peanut Butter55–5Lists seed oils and hydrogenated oils; rapeseed, soybean oil; sweetened (sugar, molasses)
116Kroger Creamy Peanut Butter55–5Lists seed oils and hydrogenated oils; rapeseed, soybean, cottonseed oil; sweetened (sugar, molasses)
117Peter Pan Creamy Peanut Butter55–5Lists seed oils and hydrogenated oils; cottonseed, rapeseed oil; sweetened (sugar)
118Smucker's Goober Grape55–11Lists artificial preservatives and corn syrups; no oil or gum; sweetened (corn syrup, dextrose)
119Reese's Spreads, Peanut Butter Chocolate47–1Lists seed oils, artificial preservatives and hydrogenated oils; canola, palm, sunflower oil; sweetened (sugar, dextrose)

The full guide · Pantry

Choosing nut butters: what to check before you buy

Start with the nut or seed you want, then choose smooth, crunchy or a flavored spread. Check added oils and sweeteners if you prefer a nuts-only recipe, and read stirring and storage instructions before choosing a large jar.

Compare price per ounce and nutrition at the same serving weight. Peanut, almond, cashew and seed spreads have different ingredients, so confirm the exact allergen information rather than treating every spread as interchangeable.

What the labels on this shelf show

We track 138 products from 28 brands on the nut butters shelf. 119 have a complete, current ingredient label on record (86%), which is what lets us score them. The other 19 stay unscored until the maker publishes a full label; a missing label is “not yet”, never a pass.

Of the 119 scored labels, 106 (89%) list none of the nine additive groups we check. The group that appears most is seed oils, listed on 12 labels, followed by hydrogenated oils on 8. 35 scored products carry a verified organic claim, which adds points. Scores here run from 47 to 100, and the typical label lists 4 ingredients.

What to compare

Nut or seed base
Choose the base and smooth or crunchy texture you want.
Added oils and sweeteners
Check the exact recipe, including no-stir and flavored spreads.
Allergen information
Read the named nuts, peanuts or seeds and any relevant advisory labeling.
Amount and storage
Compare price per ounce and read stirring and storage instructions.

Your preferences, explained

The clean score is strict and needs no setup: nine additive groups not found in a current ingredient statement, plus a verified organic claim (and a grass-fed or pasture-raised claim for animal foods), are needed for 100; a possible match earns half and a missing claim earns nothing. Missing or expired evidence stays unknown. It does not assess nutrition, allergies, contaminants, or safety.

References

  1. Nuts for the heart Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health
  2. Food allergies and allergen labeling U.S. Food and Drug Administration
  3. Added sugars on the Nutrition Facts label U.S. Food and Drug Administration
  4. Organic labeling and what the USDA Organic seal means USDA Agricultural Marketing Service

An ingredient check is not a nutrition, contaminant, allergy or safety assessment. How we verify labels →